Leg pain and leg discomfort are very common complaints. These symptoms could be due to serious medical problems or may be due to more benign disorders. If there is leg cramping, deep pain, aching in the calf muscles while walking and relieved by rest the likely diagnosis is peripheral artery disease, a lack of blood flow to the legs. This is a serious condition that should be evaluated by your doctor. When leg symptoms occur at rest, usually at night, two common processes are possible; restless leg syndrome and nocturnal leg cramps. These two disorders are often confused, but they are different entities with different treatments.
Restless leg syndrome is an uncomfortable sensation in the legs with an urge to move the legs. It most often occurs at night, but can occur while sitting in a car or plane. It does not cause pain, it lasts for a few minutes and is relieved with movement. The sensation is described as a creeping, crawling, pulling or throbbing in the legs. It is quite common, occurring in about 7% of people. There is no known cause for restless leg syndrome, but it is associated with an imbalance of a brain chemical called dopamine. It is associated with iron deficiency anemia (low blood count), neuropathy, kidney disease, Parkinson’s disease and pregnancy (affecting 3% to 30% of pregnant women). The treatment depends on the underlying cause. If there is anemia, treatment with oral or intravenous iron is beneficial. However, the vast majority of restless leg syndrome cases are idiopathic, or without known cause. For these patients, nonpharmacologic therapy can include good sleep habits, hot soaks or massage for the legs, and avoiding caffeine at bedtime. Exercise can help. Thirty minutes of aerobic exercise three times per week can improve symptoms, but avoid exercise within a few hours of bedtime. Medications such as gabapentin can relieve symptoms. The use of medications has to be tempered by the risk of side effects; the medication cannot cause significant problems since restless leg syndrome is basically a benign condition. This is the case with ropinirole (Requip). Ropinirole increases the levels of dopamine in the brain and helps symptoms when used for a short period of time (a few weeks). If used long term, symptoms of restless leg paradoxically worsen. In fact, in September 2024, the American Academy of Sleep Medicine recommended against using ropinirole for restless leg syndrome.
Nocturnal leg cramps are painful contractions of the leg muscles that occur at night. The cramps are relieved by stretching the muscle. The leg cramps (or charley horses) are common, with up to 60% of people reporting symptoms. In 20% of patients, the cramps are severe enough to cause significant insomnia. The cause of nocturnal leg cramps is not known, like restless leg syndrome an idiopathic process. Leg cramps are not associated with dehydration or low blood levels of potassium or sodium. Nocturnal leg cramps can be caused by a myriad of medications. It can also be associated with peripheral artery disease, heart artery disease, neuromuscular diseases (neuropathy, Parkinson’s disease, multiple sclerosis) and pregnancy. The acute treatment of leg cramps includes stretching and massage of the affected muscle. Mild exercise on a stationary bike or treadmill before bed can help decrease cramping. Multiple medications and supplements have been tried to relieve the symptoms of nocturnal leg cramps. However, like restless leg syndrome, the side effects of the treatments cannot be severe as the disease process itself is not severe. Quinine is a medication that has been shown to reduce the intensity of the cramps and reduce days with cramps; it reduces the number and severity of the cramps. Unfortunately, quinine has serious side effects including low platelets and heart arrythmias. In 2006, the FDA advised against using quinine for nocturnal leg cramps. Magnesium supplements have been used to prevent cramps. Unfortunately, numerous studies have failed to show any benefit. One promising avenue may be vitamin K supplementation. A recent study of 199 patients over the age of 65 showed that a vitamin K tablet decreased the frequency of leg cramps compared to placebo. In general, there are no adverse reactions with vitamin K supplementation. The only contraindication to vitamin K is in patients who are on warfarin, a blood thinner. Vitamin K is used to reverse the effect of warfarin. Vitamin K is found in green leafy vegetables such as kale, spinach, cabbage, lettuce, Brussels sprouts, cauliflower and broccoli. We don’t know whether the same reduction in leg cramping will occur with increasing the intake of vitamin K laden foods; theoretically it should. How would that work? One cup of broccoli contains 164 micrograms of vitamin K, while the supplement used in the trial had 180 micrograms. So, potentially one cup of broccoli at bedtime each night might chase those cramps away.